DENVER (AP) — A former longshot Idaho gubernatorial candidate was indicted Tuesday in the murder of Jonelle Matthews, a 12-year-old Colorado girl whose disappearance after a holiday concert in 1984 was a mystery for decades.
Steve D. Pankey was charged with murder, kidnapping and other counts in the girl’s death. He was arrested Monday at his Idaho home and being held without bail as he awaited extradition to Colorado, officials said.
Jonelle died from a single gunshot wound to her forehead, Weld County District Attorney Michael Rourke said.
Pankey ran as a Constitution Party candidate for governor in 2014 and as a Republican in the 2018 primary. He did not immediately return phone or email messages Tuesday from The Associated Press, but last week told the Times-News in Twin Falls, Idaho, that he was being framed in the case. The girl had once been a neighbor, but he said he had few other connections to Jonelle or her family.
The two families also frequented the same church in Greeley, Colorado, and Pankey had made statements to police revealing “intimate knowledge about the commission of the crime” that was not public information, Rourke said.
Jonelle disappeared on Dec. 20, 1984, after being dropped home by a friend and the friend’s father. She was last seen at 8 p.m., entering the ranch-style home where she lived with her father, Jim; mother, Gloria; and sister. But when her father returned from her older sister’s basketball game an hour later, Jonelle was gone.
The case came to the attention of then-President Ronald Reagan as his administration launched a national effort to find missing children. Her picture was printed on milk cartons across the U.S. as part of a project by the National Child Safety Council.
“For over three decades, the disappearance of Jonelle Matthews has left our community with many unanswered questions and a void that has not been filled. With the arrest of Steve Pankey … some of these questions are starting to be answered,” said Greeley police department chief Mark Jones.
Jonelle was considered missing for more than 30 years until workers digging a pipeline in July 2019 discovered human remains matching her dental records in a rural area southeast of Greeley, a city about 50 miles (80 kilometers) north of Denver. Police then labeled her death a homicide.
Pankey has been a person of interest in the case, and last year he contacted the Idaho Statesman to tell his side of the story, fearing a possible arrest.
He told the newspaper that he was home with his then-wife the night Jonelle went missing, their car packed for an early-morning trip the next day to visit family in California. They took the trip and returned home six days later in 1984, Pankey said, and heard the news of a missing child on the radio.
The ex-wife told prosecutors the trip was unexpected and on the way home, Pankey “uncharacteristically listened to the radio, searching for news accounts of Jonelle’s disappearance,” according to the indictment.
The indictment also states a 2008 incident in which Pankey’s former wife heard him say at his son’s funeral: “I hope God didn’t allow this to happen because of Jonelle Matthews.”
Jennifer Mogensen, Jonelle’s older sister told the AP in 2019 that the girl was strong and fiercely independent. In one family photo, Jonelle stood in the family’s home, with a hand on her hip. In another, she stares directly into the camera with her mouth set and eyes slightly narrowed. In countless others, her grin is wide and unguarded.
Nieberg is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.