Roth TSP option: What’s not to love?

People who work for an outfit that offers them a 401(k) option are lucky, similar to those who work for Uncle Sam. And they are doubly blessed if their employer kicks in some level of matching contributions.

That’s like feds under the Federal Employees Retirement System, who can get a 5 percent match to their Thrift Savings Plan account. Even luckier are those who have a Roth option as part of their 401(k) plan, like the government. The Roth TSP option is growing in popularity but many people still don’t understand how valuable it is, especially to younger workers.

That is where Jesse Hensley comes in. The married, 30-something fed figured out the magic of the Roth TSP option and what it will mean when he retires with a tax-free bundle of cash.

His story goes as follows:

“‘Spread your bets’ is oft-heard advice in casinos and investing. Yet, when it comes to taxes and the TSP options I do not hear the same advice as frequently.

“Both my wife and I are 15 year feds who are still relatively young, I’d like to think. We are both in our late 30s. About five years ago we began investing in the Roth TSP, roughly one year after the option became available.

“The Roth TSP option is not a Roth IRA but it shares some similarities. In the Roth TSP you contribute after-tax money, and in exchange your future principle and earnings may be withdrawn tax-free. So in other words, you are giving up a tax break today to get one in the future, which works best when you expect your future tax rates to be higher.

“Over the past five years I have had numerous eye-opening conversations with fellow feds about the upsides and downsides of switching to the Roth TSP option, which lead me to believe that there is too much prognosticating being bandied about as fact. Here is the simple reason why I like the Roth TSP option and why I think more federal employees should use it: We do not know what the future holds.

“This axiom is just as true for tax rates as it is for investing returns. I ask you to consider, as a retirement saver, the number of times you have been admonished to avoid trying to time the market. Stay the course, and of course no one can predict the next bubble. It is good advice but when it comes to taxes the conversation shifts to: in the future, you will have lower taxes and therefore, taking the tax break today in the form of the traditional TSP option is the way to go.

“But how can anyone be so sure about future tax rates? I think a more sensible strategy is to spread your bets and wind up with some money pre-tax, such as the traditional TSP, and some money post-tax, such as the Roth TSP.

“Another consideration is that your FERS pension and your Social Security will also be subject to federal taxes in retirement. If you only invest in the traditional TSP, then in effect you are making a one-way wager that your taxes in retirement will be lower.

“Keep in mind it is impossible to only invest in the Roth TSP because all matching contributions are made to the traditional TSP. For example, if you make $100,000 per year and contribute the maximum $18,500 to the Roth TSP, your 5 percent or $5,000 match will be added to the traditional TSP.

“Moreover, if you’re like my family, then you probably spent some years investing solely in the traditional TSP — a tax break today, but must you pay taxes on withdrawals later — because that was the only option available. Therefore we, and I’m guessing you, too, need to make several years’ worth of Roth TSP contributions to achieve balance between your pre- and post-tax contributions.

“In short, I don’t know what future tax rates will look like – no one does – so spreading my bets seems like the best I can do to manage my tax liability in retirement. Happy investing!”

Nearly Useless Factoid

By Amelia Brust

Researchers have said the left side of a person’s face is typically considered more pleasing than the right on camera because the left cheek expresses more emotion. Some celebrities reported to prefer, or even insist, that they only be photographed from the left side include Mariah Carey, Ariana Grande, Barbra Streisand, Seth Meyers and Barbara Walters.

Sources: Science Daily

Related Stories

Comments

Your Turn with Mike Causey

WEDNESDAYS at 10 A.M.

Learn about everything from pay, benefits and retirement, to buyouts, COLAs and pay freezes. Call the show live Wednesdays from 10-11 a.m. at 202-465-3080 with your questions. Dial 605-562-0264 to listen live from any phone. Follow Mike on Twitter and send him an email with your questions and comments. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts or Podcast One.

Sign up for breaking news alerts

THRIFT SAVINGS PLAN TICKER

Jun 18, 2021 Close Change YTD*
L Income 22.8950 -0.0718 2.88%
L 2025 11.7475 -0.0782 5.61%
L 2030 41.3301 -0.3582 7.07%
L 2035 12.3983 -0.1179 7.71%
L 2040 46.8639 -0.4865 8.36%
L 2045 12.8274 -0.1425 8.91%
L 2050 28.0756 -0.3333 9.49%
L 2055 13.7453 -0.2025 11.70%
L 2060 13.7453 -0.2024 11.70%
L 2065 13.7452 -0.2024 11.69%
G Fund 16.6073 0.0007 0.53%
F Fund 20.8808 0.0657 -2.22%
C Fund 62.4507 -0.8275 12.61%
S Fund 82.8816 -1.0758 11.60%
I Fund 38.5980 -0.6987 10.58%
Closing price updated at approx 6pm ET each business day. More at tsp.gov
* YTD data is updated on the last day of the month.