HOUSTON (AP) — A judge on Thursday granted a request by a teachers union in Texas’ largest school district to temporarily block a new system to evaluate educators that’s being implemented following a state takeover.
The order comes days after the Houston school district began its first school year under a contentious takeover that replaced its superintendent and board of trustees. It also follows rare public comments on the takeover by Texas Education Commissioner Mike Morath since he announced it in March.
One of the changes being put in place by new superintendent Mike Miles is a new teacher evaluation system that will pay educators based largely on standardized test scores and their classroom performance.
In its lawsuit, filed Wednesday in state district court, the Houston Federation of Teachers alleges the new system was approved without input from teachers and school committees, a violation of state law. The union says the new evaluation system will pit teachers against each other and not foster an environment of collaboration and improvement.
Following a court hearing Thursday, state district judge Fredericka Phillips issued the temporary restraining order, preliminarily finding that the new evaluation system was not developed under state law. A hearing to discuss whether the evaluation system would be put on hold until a trial is held was set for Sept. 11.
“Teachers at HISD do not have a problem with being evaluated. … We just want to know that we’re going to be evaluated by a system where we know what the expectation is and what the criteria is,” union president Jackie Anderson said after Thursday’s court hearing.
In a statement, the Houston school district said it can’t comment on pending litigation.
In court documents, lawyers for the school district asked that the lawsuit be dismissed because the union had failed to complete an appeals process with the Texas Education Agency before seeking court intervention. The lawyers also argued Miles did post a public notice in July seeking input from teachers and school committees for the new evaluation plan.
The state took over the school district in June, with Morath citing chronically low academic scores at one high school and allegations of misconduct by the district’s elected trustees as reasons for the action.
His most criticized change is transforming libraries at dozens of underperforming schools into “team centers” where students will get extra help and where those who misbehave will be disciplined, watching lessons on Zoom rather than disrupting their classrooms.
During a meeting in Austin Wednesday of the Texas State Board of Education, Morath expressed his support for Miles, saying that so far “a lot of very positive changes” have taken place. Morath had previously been criticized by some parents and teachers for not attending public meetings in Houston earlier this year that discussed the takeover.
But some board members questioned the impact on students of repurposing libraries as places that will be used in part for discipline.
“How is that good for kids?” asked Staci Childs, a board member who represents the Houston area.
Morath blamed concerns about the libraries to inaccurate media reports, saying the change to bring misbehaving students to an area where they can still get quality instruction is a “massive improvement.” He said the team centers will also be places for extra tutoring or for independent study for high-achieving students.
“All the books are on the shelf, none of the books have been removed. The libraries are there,” Morath said.
Board member Aicha Davis, who represents the Dallas area, pushed back against Morath’s comments.
“There will not be librarians. There won’t be anyone to guide the students. It’ll be a room with books in it, but it will not be a fully functioning library,” she said.
When asked by reporters earlier this week to evaluate how the first day of classes went on Monday, Miles gave the district a grade of A-minus.