DoD still failing to properly mark CUI data years after initial audit

“The Hill should be all over this issue but not sure anyone is paying any attention to this over there,” Bill Greenwalt said.

The Defense Department is once again under scrutiny for how it handles controlled unclassified information after a new watchdog review found persistent and widespread problems identified years ago that the department has yet to fix.

A recent management advisory from the DoD inspector general found that DoD organizations frequently failed to properly mark CUI documents with the required designation indicator block and, when they did, the organizations often defaulted to restrictive dissemination controls such as “Federal Employees and Contractors Only,” rather than using no limited dissemination control at all. 

Investigators were initially reviewing Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s use of the commercial messaging app Signal to discuss operational details of airstrikes in Yemen when they identified broader concerns related to how DoD components mark CUI, prompting the IG to issue a management advisory. 

Management advisories allow the DoD inspector general to flag urgent issues identified during an ongoing review, enabling officials to take immediate corrective action before someone requests a full-scale audit. 

But the problem is not new. In 2023, the IG’s audit of the department’s implementation and oversight of the CIU program found that nearly 50% of the reviewed documents did not include a designation indicator block at all. In addition, of the 40 different types of documents reviewed, 70% were either not marked at all or marked with outdated labels, such as “For Official Use Only,” a designation that was formally replaced more than a decade ago. At the same time, the documents that were properly marked often included restrictive dissemination controls, such as limiting access to federal employees only. 

Meanwhile, the DoD office of the under secretary of defense for intelligence and security (OUSD(I&S)), which oversees the CUI program, reported in 2023 that only 9% of CUI documents were unmarked.

“Although these statistics suggest that DoD personnel and organizations have minor deficiencies in either understanding how to properly mark or in marking CUI documents, the sample from the DoD IG indicates that the issue is more pervasive,” the DoD IG report reads.

Of the 14 recommendations the IG made back in 2023, eight have been closed and six remain open.

“We continue to follow up on all open recommendations until they are resolved and closed,” the IG office told Federal News Network.

The CUI program was established in 2010 as a governmentwide framework to standardize how sensitive but unclassified information is handled. The Defense Department formally implemented its version of the program in 2020, tasking the intelligence and security office with overseeing policy, training and compliance. 

But the IG found that “conflicting and insufficient” guidance and training and a lack of enforcement caused personnel to default to restrictive markings or avoid marking documents altogether.

Failures to properly mark CUI have significant implications as overly restrictive markings limits DoD’s ability to share information with Congress and other agencies, while unmarked data forces contractors to choose between absorbing additional costs outside the scope of the contract or risking a security incident.

“After reading this, I am struck by what an outrageous system CUI has become. We now have this second level of classified information that the department is using that far exceeds the SCI/TS/Secret system. While there have been ample criticisms of the traditional classified system, this new CUI system appears to be completely out of control. While it is already costing the government and industry billions a year to comply with it just through the [Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification] process, there has been little debate on the need or the effects of CUI in the public or in Congress,” Bill Greenwalt, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a former deputy undersecretary of defense for industrial policy, told Federal News Network.

“While the IG report essentially has identified that the department may be arbitrarily restricting some information under the CUI by not getting the markings right, what I am struck by is the proliferation of new markings that expands how CUI is used. The FED ONLY or FEDCON classifications are just new versions of how the executive branch keeps Congress and the public in the dark. The Hill should be all over this issue but not sure anyone is paying any attention to this over there,” he added.

In its 2026 advisory, the IG issued five recommendations. The intelligence and security office has updated the Frequently Asked Questions training aid on the DoD CUI Program website, but recommendations to revise guidance and training documents to clarify the implications of using limited dissemination controls such as ‘Federal Employees and Contractors Only’ and ‘Federal Employees Only’ remain open.

“The DoD CUI program is an important aspect of the department’s overall information security program. With this in mind, of the five recommendations issued by the DoD IG on February 4, 2026, two have already been resolved and closed (1.a and 1.b.4). The remaining three are open but will be resolved and closed before the end of the fiscal year,” a DoD official told Federal News Network.

Copyright © 2026 Federal News Network. All rights reserved. This website is not intended for users located within the European Economic Area.

Related Stories

    Congress Speaker

    While $350 billion reconciliation bill is dead, top Republican says there is path for smaller package

    Read more
    FILE - This March 12, 2013 photo shows the air traffic control tower at Chicago's Midway International Airport.  The Department of Homeland Security plans to issue a security alert Tuesday for small planes, warning that modern flight systems are vulnerable to hacking if someone manages to gain physical access to the aircraft. A DHS alert recommends that plane owners ensure they restrict unauthorized physical access to their aircraft until the industry develops safeguards to address the issue, which was discovered by Boston-based cybersecurity company, Rapid7, and reported to the federal government.  (AP Photo/M. Spencer Green)

    Q&A: How civil air traffic control outages affect military flights

    Read more