It’s not all doom and gloom when it comes to government customer service.
Though the public generally has an unfavorable view of government customer services — the federal government earned a 68.9 out of 100 on the American Customer Satisfaction Index last year — those perceptions miss the whole story, according to a new report from the Partnership for Public Service and Accenture Federal Services.
Individual, highly-used agency services often fare better than the government as whole. Customers gave the IRS and Medicare’s main hot lines, once they got through to a representative, a satisfaction score of more than 90%, according to the agencies.
The State Department’s Bureau of Consular Affairs received an 87% satisfaction score from customers applying for a passport.
But those positive scores aren’t indicative across all of government, and agencies often struggle to provide a consistent customer experience across all of their services.
That means agencies have an opportunity to raise their game, Max Stier, president and CEO for the Partnership, said Tuesday at an annual customer experience summit in Washington.
Here are some ideas and best practices — directly from the agencies attempting to improve their own customer experiences.
Get top leadership involved
Assigning a senior executive or an experienced employee to oversee and track your agency’s progress in meeting specific customer experience goals can help, the Partnership said.
The trademarks office at the Patent and Trademarks Office assigned a GS-14 to manage and design a customer experience plan for the organization.
“We have built up a whole group around the customer experience administrator,” Mary Boney Denison, trademarks commissioner for PTO, said. “It just started with this one position and then we expanded it. We now have a team of web strategists and plain language writers who are helping us.”
Based on the trademark office’s experience, PTO’s patents office last year launched its own customer experience team, Denison said.
The IRS is embarking on a journey to improve its online services through a six-year integrated modernization business plan. The goal, the agency has said, is to change the way it does business and interacts with the public.
IRS Commissioner Chuck Rettig acknowledged the agency’s modernization initiatives could create change that might be uncomfortable for its employees.
“We have to make decisions that’s not going to make every one of our employees’ lives better, but I’m telling them very openly where we’re headed and the decisions we’re having to make,” he said. “These decisions are not going to make it better for them tomorrow or the next day, but in five, six, seven years, we’re hoping to get the employees’ world better.”
Rettig said he wants the agency’s employees, who he refers to as “IRS ambassadors,” to be proud of where they work and what they do.
For Rettig, the drive to develop a culture of stellar customer experience is a personal one. His wife came to the United States as a refugee, and his in-laws don’t speak English.
Rettig said taxpayers like those in his family are most impacted by the IRS’ customer service delays, which were compounded further by the 35-day government shutdown earlier this year. The agency had to cancel some 16,000 taxpayer appointments during the lapse in appropriations, according to the National Taxpayer Advocate.
“It’s unacceptable,” Rettig said. “It’s unacceptable that a person in this country ends up in that situation, but we’re in that situation. Every agency has some variation of this situation. We’re moving forward with our eyes on the people who we interact with. Principally, that’s lower income people, English-as-a-second language or non-English speaking folks.”
PTO also acknowledged culture change is necessary to achieve a better customer experience, up to and including its new hires. The agency began to screen new examining attorneys for characteristics and qualities of empathy, Denison said.
“We hired 83 new lawyers last year,” she said. “All of them were asked questions that gauged their empathy level, because they’re going to be speaking directly to the public. If you don’t have empathy then you’re not going to probably be very good at the customer experience.”
Improve online services and social media
The Education Department’s Federal Student Aid Office began a concerted effort to speak to students and borrowers about their experiences with the FSA a few years ago.
Students and borrowers helped FSA identify “pain points” within the organization, Mark Brown, chief operating officer for the agency, said. Based on those focus groups and conversations, FSA learned some 15-to-16% of applicants used their mobile phones to complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA).
More agencies should adopt FSA’s approach, the Partnership said, because many government websites are still riddled with complex language or confusing layouts.
In addition, social media can be another valuable tool, especially if agencies can use it to correct or clarify inaccurate information. TSA has been especially successful with this practice, the Partnership said.
“We’re out there looking at what people are saying, correcting bad information and providing real time, accurate information to travelers,” Kimberly Walton, TSA’s executive assistant administrator for enterprise support, said.
Agencies are gathering their own, direct customer feedback instead of relying on outside surveys, which can’t often show comments immediately after a specific experience.
But agencies don’t or can’t often share this data, so it’s difficult for the public and other agencies to see how well they’re doing.
“That’s largely due to restrictions in the Paperwork Reduction Act,” Kathy Conrad, director of digital government for Accenture Federal Services, said. “It means that not only can the public not have the benefit of seeing the feedback that they provide on customer experience but it also means that agencies have a more difficult time … in being able to compare their experiences to those of peer agencies finding models that they may want to replicate.”
The Federal Agency Customer Experience Act, which cleared the Senate this summer, would overcome some of the burdens of the Paperwork Reduction Act. The bill would allow agencies to collect customer feedback through short, voluntary surveys developed by the Office of Management and Budget.
OMB, the Partnership said, could also help agencies collect and publish common customer experience measures, so organizations and the public can compare them.